Alliances That Create Value
-The ANA Group’s Alliance Strategy for Its International Business-
The ANA Group has strong operating fundamentals in its domestic network, but as a latecomer has remained relatively weak in its international network. ANA’s fi rst international fl ight was in 1986.
We have been expanding our own operations, but at the same time, we have relied heavily on our partner airlines to cover a wider network and increase our revenue.
Joining Star Alliance, the largest alliance in the world, was a big step forward for ANA. Since we became a member of Star Alliance, our strategy for international business has continued to evolve. This feature explores the background of the alliance in the airline industry and the progress and future of the ANA Group’s alliance strategy for its international business through an interview with Mio Yamamuro of the ANA Alliances & International Affairs Department, whose experience includes a secondment at Star Alliance headquarters.
The History of Airline Industry Alliances
Alliances with partner carriers are the centerpiece of the ANA Group’s international network. Please explain how the alliance strategy was established and current trends in the airline industry.
The enforcement of the Airline Deregulation Act in the United States in 1978 initiated the liberalization of the airline industry, while the Open Skies1 concept that became broadly accepted in 1995 provided the opportunity to construct today’s global networks. This agreement liberalized regulations governing traffic volume, fares and location entry and permitted code-sharing and other new forms of operation.
Code-sharing allows alliance partners to use their own flight codes and numbers on their partners’ flights as the marketing carrier.
It therefore strengthens marketing capabilities by expanding the respective networks of alliance partners and by adding value to frequent flyer programs through mileage accrual.
Code-sharing and other commercial relationships among airlines have currently developed into three global alliances. ANA is a member of Star Alliance, which five airlines inaugurated in 1997 around a core alliance between United Airlines and Lufthansa. British Airways and American Airlines are the nucleus of oneworld, which was formed in 1998. SkyTeam was launched in 2000 with members KLM Royal Dutch Airlines, Air France, Delta Air Lines and others; in 2002, it merged with the Wings Alliance that was formed in 1993.
Over the past several years, advanced partnerships called “Joint Ventures” have formed within these global alliances.
Several of these global Joint Ventures are operating today.
1. The United States and the Netherlands signed the first Open Skies agreement between the two countries in 1992.
Global Alliance Trends
Where are the global alliances heading?
What are their strategies?
In addition to expanded networks, including the use of code-share flights, the fundamental merits of global alliances are 1) seamless travel through the use of shared airport terminals; 2) improved competitiveness through frequent flyer programs; 3) shared facilities such as airport lounges; and 4) minimization of costs from joint purchasing of goods such as in-flight service items and jet fuel. Moreover, alliances conduct periodic reciprocal safety audits and assist members in dealing with unexpected incidents. Alliances regularly conduct drills and prepare themselves so that they can initiate immediate action to handle emergencies. Such action includes setting up customer support, information gathering and linguistic support. Each global alliance has concentrated on improving competitiveness through these types of initiatives, but the emergence of LCCs and other factors are reshaping the airline industry’s landscape. In addition to competition among alliances, airlines must now compete with LCCs that do not belong to any alliance as well as Middle Eastern carriers. Continental Airlines changed its alliance from SkyTeam to Star Alliance in October 2009, which exemplifies the complexity of the landscape. We are also witnessing an increase in the number of airlines that are partnering with airlines from other alliances. These types of partnerships are the result of aggressive competition and complicated route networks. We may even see more dynamic changes in the future.
Joint Venture Trends
How can you best describe the sophisticated partnership, the Joint Venture?
A Joint Venture is a strategic partnership that can be commenced with antitrust immunity (ATI) approval. ATI is granted on the condition that the approved Joint Venture would bring various benefits to travelers such as improved flight schedules and discounted airfares.(Please refer to page 34 for a detailed explanation of the term.)
Before Joint Ventures existed, network coordination, marketing and pricing discussions among carriers were prohibited by antitrust laws in each country. However, after Joint Ventures began, airlines were able to coordinate networks, flight frequencies and schedules as well as provide discounted and harmonized fares to the market.
These initiatives have been designed to maximize the revenues of the Joint Venture as a whole, and the revenues are pooled and shared among the Joint Venture partner carriers in accordance with a certain methodology. A Joint Venture is in fact a joint business that extends beyond existing partnerships encompassing simply code-sharing or being a member of a global alliance.
The first Joint Venture started in 1992 between KLM Royal Dutch Airlines and Northwest Airlines (its name at the time) with ATI approval. The first Joint Venture among Star Alliance carriers was formed by United Airlines, Air Canada and Lufthansa in their trans-Atlantic routes. After 20 years, the Joint Ventures themselves are now more sophisticated and able to bring more benefits to travelers, and at the same time they create value and increase competitiveness for participating carriers.
Joint Venture
A joint business in the international airline industry between two or more airlines, based upon ATI approval from their respective governments/ authorities. There are varieties such as revenue-sharing Joint Ventures and profit-sharing Joint Ventures. By forming a Joint Venture, airlines in the same global alliance are able to offer travelers a broader, more flexible network along with less expensive fares, thus strengthening their competitiveness against other alliances (or Joint Ventures).
Restrictions such as bilateral air agreements between countries and caps on foreign capital investments still exist in the international airline industry. Therefore, airlines form an ATI-based Joint Venture, instead of the commonly known methods used in other industries such as capital tie-ups and M&As, etc.